Sleuth Home - Message Boards - Sleuth Talk

Jul-14-2007 17:13

"Lie detection" (or some better sounding name preferably):

Works just like Stress detection in that it "gives you a free question", but is a Smarts-skill instead of Toughness. And when someone gives you an alibi it gives you a message (sometimes or always?) that says something along the lines of "You sense that she/he is telling the truth" or "It's quite apparent that she/he is lying". Thus you won't have to check the alibi, and effectively save a question.

Please comment. It's not a finished idea.

Jul-15-2007 06:41

Hej

http://noir.playsleuth.com/map/cityhall/post.spy?id=70&first_record=626

http://noir.playsleuth.com/map/cityhall/post.spy?id=8707&first_record=71404

http://noir.playsleuth.com/map/cityhall/post.spy?id=15681&first_record=122128

There are heaps and heaps more posts similar to these about skill suggestions.

Using the Search feature on the boards can help a lot and make for an interesting read.

Hejdå

Jul-16-2007 16:05

So.. anyway, this skill was meant to be a Smarts equivalent to Lockpicking and Stress detection. Those are both Toughness. Perhaps there's a reason for Toughness getting two "get a free question"-skills. Research has a similar function too, but you can only research once per case I think..

But the above is all I've come up with so far. I meant that a discussion could evolve the idea perhaps into something complete enough to go into the game.

Jul-16-2007 19:17

Stress detection is not a "get a free question" skill, to be technical. You don't gain extra questions from it.

Jul-16-2007 23:54

Yes. Right. I meant more like a discount coupon where you save some questions of the regular price. It's a common misnomer. Thanks for the correction though.

Jul-17-2007 00:13

Acutually, research would probably fit more with the description you are giving. Stress detection is more like having a sixth sense about when someone is going to clam.

Jul-17-2007 05:35

Ok. Make it research then. Whatever floats your boat. So what's people's take on the idea? Is it too similar in function to Research?

Jul-17-2007 05:39

I don't agree that this is needed. The ability to rule more people out will make cases to easy and take the fun away. Also was lie detection available and at all reliable in the 1920's and 30's? I don't know, it's never been used here in the UK in courts of law.

Jul-17-2007 06:38

I'm not particularly against this. I wonder though if the cases need to be made easier than they already are? If you get 'all' the skills there are right now, and you're just doing normal agency AI's you'd hardly ever quit a case. Even with VH's you'd only quit what about 2 or 3 'maybe' out of 12 if you were having a really bad run.

It's about at the point that if you were going to 'add' more skills to an already large list that you start to get into the realms of and/or. eg You can have Hypnotism or The Lie Detector, but NOT both.

I like the idea of new skills :) but not at the expense of the game getting too easy.

Jul-17-2007 08:36

I agree with SS but perhaps this skill would be better suggested for SOM?

Jul-17-2007 10:04

Even with VH's you'd only quit what about 2 or 3 'maybe' out of 12 if you were having a really bad run.

Apparently SS isnt having the same kind of bad days I have :p