Sleuth Home - Message Boards - Newbie Questions

Dec-22-2017 19:15

Hi, i just have a quick question
if you have 2 or more people that know or heard something suspicious, does that mean if both those people say they dont suspect X, mean that X is not the killer?
in other words can there be 2 seperate witness evidences pointing to 2 separate suspects both of which have real alibis?

Dec-26-2017 17:08

I had cases where 2 different real alibi suspects each had 1 WE against them.

I wouldn't be surprised if you could pair all real alibi suspect with 1 WE. In AI cases you don't have that many questions to find out.

Dec-27-2017 17:31

Yea Sindy youre right
actually i believe that if 3 people who think they know who the murderer is, all say that they have no reason to suspect jane doe implies jane doe is not the murderer
but 2 people saying no isnt enough because you could have 2 different suspects with 2 real alibis have a WE against each one of them