Sleuth Home - Message Boards - Sleuth : Shades of Mystery


0 0
Noir vs. Shades
  <<First Page  |  <Previous  

Clint Forthwright
Clint Forthwright
Old Shoe

May-27-2009 06:08

Tell us why you play Sleuth Noir instead of Shades of Mystery. Or if you play both, which one you like more and why.

Example: Shades doesn't leave enough to the imagination. There's no scripted mysteries.

Replies

ctown28
ctown28
Tireless Tiger

May-27-2009 08:52

No Worries Clint, I will go ahead and move it over the the Shades of Mystery board! :-D

Lady Jas
Lady Jas
The Chosen One

May-27-2009 22:23

Clint,

The thread below you "Noir/Shades" by phoenixfyre has some good stuff in there.

Lady Jas
Lady Jas
The Chosen One

May-27-2009 22:24

For me, I personally like Noir better. I've played both and still am active over there to an extent, but Noir will always be my home :D

Jackina
Jackina

Jul-5-2009 17:18

I like Shades better. You get to go to the crime scene and actually look for clues. Plus i think you can connect with the characters in the game better.But Noir is pretty cool to.

Rosamund Clifford
Rosamund Clifford
Tale Spinner

Jul-8-2009 01:11

I like Noir infinitely better, but there's no disputing about tastes. However, there's a part of the Shades that we could possibly "copy" here, and this is the showdown. Maybe we could have it three times a day, and it could be accessed from any bar, including the Sleuthetania. In my opinion, it would add some liveliness to our beloved, but at the moment a little bit stale game. I've never taken part in one, but there are people who play both Noir and the Shades whose experiences and ideas would be most welcome.

Marissa Peterson
Marissa Peterson
Old Shoe

Jul-12-2009 17:54

That sounds like a neat idea to me!! ;-D

Oh Nicnic!! Found another somethin' for your improvement thread!! ;-)

Vulkie3
Vulkie3
Haynes

Jul-12-2009 22:08

Noir has some options that shades hasn't (yet). Like for instance,scripted mysteries. I love to replay scripted mysteries,cuz they are well composed and have an interesting plot.

Also,Noir has a better "view" then shades. In shades,it's one city,divided in three parts. Here in Noir,we have 5 city's (shangri-la isn't a city in my opinion), with all kinds of neat stuff. Like racetrack,pyramids etc.

And as a last point,we have AVH's here in Noir. Ah,do we love them guys? Chasing badguys around the world xD.

So,for me,Noir is best ^-^

Secret Spy_
Secret Spy_
Super Steeper

Apr-2-2010 07:02

Me too!
I like Noir a lot!

Tagasiyasat
Tagasiyasat

May-9-2010 22:37

Well, for me, Noir and Shades are both special in their own ways. Noir has scripted mysteries and different cities, and in Shades you can explore the crime scene and find clues in suspects' houses. Although there is one thing bothering me about Shades. The deadline. I mean, it can help solve mysteries faster in the future, but I think that like Noir, they should give us enough time. Anyone agree with me?

Bela Talbot II
Bela Talbot II

Feb-27-2013 04:36

Love Noir, though we could have the SDs here; that would be awesome.

  <<First Page  |  <Previous  

[ You must login to reply ]