Sleuth Home - Message Boards - The Gumshoe Lounge


0 0
Shelock Holmes
  <<First Page  |  <Previous  

Charlie Cain
Charlie Cain
Thespian

Jul-30-2009 18:39

Did you know there is a new movie about ole Sherlock coming out some time with in the next year? Yep its gonna have Robert Downey Jr. as the main character and Judd Law as Dr. Watson. Its supposed to be base on a graphic novel version of the detective who changed literary sleuthing. Its gonna focus on Holmes's martial abilities. I hope its gonna be good. I have been hoping for a good mystery movie for sometime. If anyone has any referals it would be greatly appreciated. Although my selection is quite thin for the time being I can always have my wife ship them to me.

Replies

Cordelia Falco
Cordelia Falco
Battered Shoe

Jan-9-2010 08:40

"I strongly dislike Hollywood's love for turning someone into a comical sidekick all of the time. If it's not Dr Watson who's incorrectly portrayed as a daft, stumbling fool it's Gimli or Ron Weasley."

Couldn't agree more, Encyclopedia Zero, well said!

Encyclopedia Zero
Encyclopedia Zero
Well-Connected

Jan-10-2010 06:39

I gotta add something, or possibly revise my "review" here:

The more and more I think of the movie (which I will be revisiting the theatre to watch at least once more before it's out on DVD) the more I like it. The movie is a great, thrilling adventure and as such it succeeds. But it succeeds EVEN MORE as an adaptation of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle's Sherlock Holmes.

I should add that from what I hear from far bigger fans than myself that they consider the movie close to perfect, and that they are sorry that so many people claim to be fans and know the character and complain about the movie being inaccurate. This just makes me want to find all the stories I have not yet read and study the character even more. At least I appear to be "getting it" which is a relief.

----------------------------------

Anikka, I see. But that would be a problem at the local theatre and not an unsolvable problem with the film. If that happens again ask them to turn the volume down a bit. Or perhaps watch it over again on DVD when it comes out. ;)

Molly Maltese
Molly Maltese
Old Shoe

Jan-10-2010 12:16

Hollywood plays to their audience. In general, movie viewers want simple, understandable characters and heavy comic relief, so characters (such as Watson, Gimli and Ron Weasley) are cheapened for the sake of raking in more money. One cannot POSSIBLY go to a movie these days and expect true artistic integrity in an adaptation, however I think they really did Sherlock Holmes justice straight from casting. RDJ is a wizard at acting, and he's quite adept at the snarky, sarcastic characters which makes Sherlock Holmes seem like a second-skin to him (see his nomination for Best Actor. ;D) Not only that, rather than selling out Watson, they cast a capable actor, who though well-known, does NOT take silly roles generally. I was SO happy that rather than blatant, in-your-face potty jokes, the humor came from their interactions together, and lurked just under every quip and line as they bantered on like brothers. For me, RDJ and Jude Law's relationship on-screen as Holmes and Watson made the movie for me.


Lord Blackwood was pretty B.A. too. ;D

Anikka
Anikka
Babelfish

Jan-10-2010 13:24

I agree with everything you said, Molly, except your last line.

Every time I saw him, I just wanted to slap his face and tell him to get over himself. The actor was excellent, as he obviously played the part well enough to get a reaction from me (!), but I don't think it was the reaction they were going for. B.A.? Nah, just a self-serving J.A. But that's just my opinion. :-D

When I watched the movie, I also had Sam the Rose's comment in mind (regarding Irene Adler being classy, not a tart) and I have to say that I didn't consider the movie Adler to be at all tart-ish. Even when running around in a suit of men's clothes, she was a lady. I don't believe that she would have dealt with anyone else the way she dealt with Holmes; that behaviour was for him alone.

Molly Maltese
Molly Maltese
Old Shoe

Jan-10-2010 13:59

Well, as far as villains go he was quite...villainous, which is all I meant by the B.A. classfication, I wanted to slap him silly as well! :D

Waking up handcuffed to the bed= hilarious. Sherlock's line to the maid= more hilarious.

Even when she had a knife at that guys throat in the alley, it was oddly gentile. What a fun role!

Encyclopedia Zero
Encyclopedia Zero
Well-Connected

Jan-11-2010 13:37

Here's an article:

http://www.examiner.com/examiner/x-32109-Orange-County-Movie-Examiner~y2010m1d2-Sherlockians-critics-and-audience-react-to-the-new-Sherlock-Holmes

Anikka
Anikka
Babelfish

Jan-11-2010 13:59

Very interesting article, thank you for sharing it, Ency.

I was amused to see a picture from one of my very favourite Sherlock Holmes movies, 'Without A Clue'. Obviously, it was completely tongue-in-cheek - Michael Caine plays a cheerfully unintelligent drunkard actor hired to play the part of a non-existent Sherlock Holmes... by Ben Kingsley's Dr. Watson, the brains of the outfit. It was Dr. Watson who had solved all the crimes in the stories he wrote, but thanks to the publisher, the character Sherlock Holmes was created - and then all of London wanted to hire him.

It was the most inaccurate portrayal of Holmes ever done; then again, it was a parody.

M. Lacrimosa
M. Lacrimosa
Sleuth About Town

Jan-13-2010 17:44

For those of you who have not yet seen the movie, nor read any of the stories, I should go ahead and tell you that you should read the short story A Scandal in Bohemia before you see the movie. Irene Adler is a character in the movie and if you haven't read that story then you will have no clue how she and Sherlock Holmes know each other.

Encyclopedia Zero
Encyclopedia Zero
Well-Connected

Jan-18-2010 15:55

I suggest you read all of his stories. There's 56 of the short ones I think and four novels. If you do you will have a good idea of the character unlike those who only know him from earlier film or tv carnations. The latter will be greatly disappointed by the movie while those familiar with the original character Sherlock Holmes won't.

  <<First Page  |  <Previous  

[ You must login to reply ]