Sleuth Home - Message Boards - Newbie Questions

Dec-4-2008 14:21

what can you do when you know who did it, but they don't have a motive and all the other characters won't talk.

I have a character with a fake alibi and a witness pointing to them. But, no motive.

Help...

Dec-4-2008 15:02

Since you cannot accuse someone who has no motive, you have no choice but to quit the case, if you cannot get anyone else to talk.

Dec-4-2008 15:22

poo....

Thank you. I will start a new case then! thanks!

Dec-5-2008 12:52

What do I do too please?

Dec-5-2008 13:03

Cass.....the answer hasnt changed lol ;) Just being friendly..anyway, if you have that same problem....you do as Anikka said......quit the case :)

Dec-6-2008 06:21

Just this situation is the reason why many players with experience consider the motive question the most important question. While the tutorial slightly got me feel the alibi question was the most important...

Dec-6-2008 06:32

FYI: the motive question is the most important because if you don't have all the suspects you lessen your chance of having the guilty one in your list.

Alibi is less important because you can still determine guilt without it.

*tips hat*

Dec-6-2008 09:40

I agre e with Barry.....I definitely ask motive first to make sure I have all the suspects

Dec-6-2008 16:37

Problem with determining guilt without the alibi, are that you need the answer from two suspects, and if your case are so clammy you will have to choose between motive and alibi, you are very likely to not get those 2 witness evidences to accuse without being guessing, and hence have the option of getting a false accusation.
It's true that you migth not get all the suspects if you choose alibi before motive, on the other hand, all the suspects's motive can be given by 2 other suspects, while the alibi can only be given by the suspect him/herself. Also, I have the experience that more often than seldom, even if I don't have all the suspects, when the case is clammed up, I do have the guilty one among the suspects. This have even been true when I had only 3 suspects on an AI case.
But, of course, I have only done some 10 000 cases, so I guess people with more experience will know better than me. And, besides, I don't really know what's the most important question to ask.... There are so many factors weighing all directions.

Dec-6-2008 16:44

Actually....I have accused on one answer from suspect,(witness evidence) but then, they had a fake alibi too . I wont do that if I dont have an alibi lol I think its just personal choice, is what it comes down to. :)

In my opinion, the most important question to ask, still, is motive. If you dont have the suspects motive, and he or she ends up to be the guilty one, you can't accuse them..which means a quit case.

To each their own, I guess :)

Dec-7-2008 09:36

Since there's a known formula for how many people will have fake alibis for each level of case, then as long as you have all the suspects it's often possible to deduce whether one suspect has a false or real alibi. For this reason I think it's better to ask motive first.