Anikka
Babelfish
|
May-23-2008 14:07
Well, one thing that everyone needs to remember is that Sleuth was created by and is maintained basically by one person (two people, when Sunny has time in her also-busy life). This is Ben's game and he made it what he wanted it to be. Maybe he will use people's ideas (Sleuthetania), and maybe he won't (ponies... *snerk*).
This game is SLEUTH, not CRIMINAL, hence the fact that everyone is a detective, not a criminal. The cases are basically logic puzzles. Allowing an arch-criminal from randomly making you lose a case goes against the grain of logic puzzles.
If you are unhappy with the way the game is, why not go create a game of your own? That way, you could have all the things you want in it. This is not a sarcastic suggestion, by the way - it's a very genuine one. You could set it in whatever time period you want to, and have whatever types of events and ideas and puzzles and such that you want.
Perhaps the reason that the majority of other players (at least that post on the boards) do not seem to care for all your ideas is that many of them would cause Sleuth Noir to no longer be Sleuth Noir. If you were to create a new game, not only would you have the satisfaction of seeing your ideas in use, but the people who want to see those ideas in action would have a chance to do so.
Seriously, if you are bored, or if you don't like the game, then figure out what would make you not bored or what you do like and go create it!
|
Anikka
Babelfish
|
May-26-2008 01:53
On the contrary, VS, it was not an attack at all, nor was it meant as one. And I'm not really sure how it targeted unsubbed players in your eyes. Be that as it may, I can see that a perfectly honest suggestion has no merit in your eyes. That is too bad, since I'd be interested to see what kind of game you would create and what mechanics would be a part of it.
|
Glorious Jade
|
Jun-15-2008 19:09
I'm with Anikka. Your ideas are great but would in fact, change Sleuth to the point where it's not Sleuth anymore. Also, no one's attacking anyone and yes, I read the entire thread. This is a place to share suggestions and ideas, no?
|